Fraser Nelson

A welcome rejection of assisted suicide

A welcome rejection of assisted suicide
Text settings

I'm delighted that Lord Falconer has just failed in his attempt to legalise assisted suicide for people sending friends and relatives to Swiss death clinics. This is a topic which I suspect even CoffeeHousers will be evenly divided on, but to me the whole idea is just wrong - and it goes straight to the heart of how we, as a society, regard the disabled and the elderly. For those who haven't been following the debate, Falconer used the Coroners and Justice Bill to propose a new law to make it legal to help one's friends and relatives be killed in the Swiss death clinics. He proposed that any two doctors can be "of the opinion in good faith" that someone is terminally ill, yet mentally coherent enough to make the decision to go to Switzerland for the lethal injection. The debate in the Lords was excellent, and flagged up the many problems with this. First off, the doctors have said they want nothing to do with this. Perhaps because they know that diagnoses can be wrong. As we heard from the (excellent) Lords report:

"The Royal College of Pathologists drew attention to 'a 30% error rate in the medically-certified cause of death', with 'significant errors (i.e. misdiagnosis of a terminal illness resulting in inappropriate treatment) in about 5% of cases.'"

So one in 20 terminal illness is wrongly diagnosed - ergo, people could be sent to their deaths for no reason. And, even if the diagnoses were 100 percent correct, imagine what would happen if the principle were established. If we, as a society, decided that lives are disposable - that there was an officially sanctioned "off" switch - then how would that make our elderly feel? My concern is that it would plant in their heads a nagging question: should they do the decent thing, and ask to be sent to Switzerland so as not to be a burden?

One final thing, that I have never quite understood - and perhaps CoffeeHousers may have some thoughts. This issue is often portrayed as religious groups v the rest. Certainly, Christian and Muslim groups are very opposed to any legislation that promotes abortion or euthanasia - but should this be confined to them? Do you really have to believe in God to believe in the sanctity of life?

So Lord Falconer has been sent homewards to think again tonight. If he is such a supporter of assisted suicide, he can go and help the Labour Party get on with it. I'm glad that tonight, he's been told (by 194 votes to 141) to leave the rest of us alone.

Written byFraser Nelson

Fraser Nelson is the editor of The Spectator. He is also a columnist with The Daily Telegraph, a member of the advisory board of the Centre for Social Justice and the Centre for Policy Studies.

Topics in this articleSocietyhouse of lordsuk politics