Pieter Cleppe

Britain must fight the EU’s nanny state urges

The UK government has given the EU a Brexit deadline of four months. No. 10 is threatening to walk away from the negotiating table if a broad outline for a Canada-style trade agreement cannot be reached by the summer. 

But the UK isn’t really being as radical as it might first appear. For a start, the withdrawal agreement already commits the parties to a July deadline by which point the EU must decide whether to extend the transition period. 

Some might argue that the UK is ripping up the political declaration by imposing such a deadline. But in fact, the UK is only applying a minimalist interpretation of the non-binding political declaration, arguing that ‘regression in social or environmental policy should only be banned when trade is distorted. The EU, on the other hand, wants the UK to respect its ‘high standards’ in return for tariff-free access to the bloc.

The backdrop to this is that the EU – or at least its chief Brexit negotiator, Michel Barnier – thinks that when the EU has more trade with a country, it justifies more protectionism. Barnier is using this as a justification to impose more conditions on the UK than Canada. In reality, this protectionism will of course damage the EU as well, especially if it’s applied not to prevent new trade, but to destroy existing trade.

A key Johnson demand in the negotiations is for the right to set the UK’s own rules and thereby ‘diverge’ from EU ones. Perhaps it would be a wise thing to implement this gradually, but ultimately UK concessions on the pace of implementation will only be possible if Brussels accepts that current trade flows will not be harmed simply because the UK wants to make their own rules.

It doesn’t really look like we are heading that way. In the past, the EU has been guilty of over-regulation.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in