Houman Barekat

Double trouble: August Blue, by Deborah Levy, reviewed

Elsa, a concert pianist, is starting to panic. Her adoptive father is dying, and she keeps meeting her doppleganger, fuelling an obsession with her origins

Deborah Levy. [David Levenson/Getty Images]

The narrator-protagonist of Deborah Levy’s August Blue, an elite-level concert pianist called Elsa, is going through a difficult time. She recently walked off stage after messing up a Rachmaninoff recital in Vienna. More worryingly, she has just dyed her hair blue. At a market stall in Athens, she becomes entranced by a pair of novelty mechanical horses, but they’re snapped up by another customer with whom she becomes fixated. Elsa keeps noticing ‘the horse woman’ out and about, and starts to think of her as ‘a sort of psychic double’. She is deeply impressed when she sees her smoking a large cigar: ‘It was a poke at life. A provocation. She had attitude and confidence.’

The novel follows Elsa as she gives piano lessons to the children of wealthy people in Athens, London and Paris, before decamping to Sardinia to spend time with her terminally ill adoptive father Arthur. She snacks on sea urchins and tomatillos and reconnects with an old friend who got fat in lockdown.

Gradually, her backstory emerges. We learn that Arthur, who is also a musician, had adopted her as a child prodigy, primarily ‘in order to teach me’. She never knew her mother, and had seen Arthur more as a tutor than a dad. Now that he’s dying, she wants closure on the circumstances surrounding her adoption. Her bizarre obsession with the random woman seems to be a manifestation of unresolved psychic baggage from her childhood in rural Suffolk. So too, perhaps, is her compulsive wanderlust, which inspires a sarcastic reproach from her father’s partner: ‘I see you are interested in Montichiari, but you don’t want to know about Ipswich.’

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.


Unlock more articles



Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in