Bruce Anderson

Eric Hobsbawm: a life-long apologist for the Soviet Union

In last week’s Spectator, Sam Leith reviewed Eric Hobsawm’s Fractured Times. Our ex-political editor and drink critic Bruce Anderson thinks Leith has missed a basic point about Hobsbawm’s career. Here is Anderson’s riposte in full:

In his review of Eric Hobsbawm’s ‘Fractured Times’ (Spectator, 23 March). Sam Leith misses the basic point: the basic treason. Throughout his career, Professor Hobsbawm was an apologist for the Soviet Union. This was forgivable in the 1930s, During that desperate decade, many thoughtful people despaired of liberal democracy and believed that they had found solace in Moscow. But after 1945, as the evidence mounted, Eric the Red kept the faith. Towards the end of his life, he said that it would have been worth twenty million dead to create a socialist society. Twenty million: pause for a minute, gentle reader, and try to begin to imagine their sufferings.

Hobsbawm’s hideous allegiance led him into a fundamental historical misjudgment. In his life as much is in his writings, he was a chronicler of the glories of pre-1914 old European high culture, especially in Vienna. But he never fully acknowledged the debt all that owed to the bourgeois social order, which promoted prosperity, the rule of law and free institutions, and which seemed – in Europe, at least – to be enabling mankind to make a decisive break with scarcity and oppression. For a generation after the second fall of man in 1914, everything went wrong. Then there was a gradual recovery, which again owed everything to a bourgeois social order. But Hobsbawn would have preferred an order imposed by the Red Army.

‘Army’ brings us to General Pinochet.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in