Roy Foster

How can Ireland survive the seismic changes of the past three decades?

Economic boom and bust, mass immigration, the crumbling power of the Catholic Church and the fallout from Brexit are just some of the upheavals the Irish have experienced since 1995

Protestors in Dublin in November 2010 hold a placard depicting the Irish prime minster Brian Cowen (left) and the minister of finance Brian Lenihan (right). About 50,000 took to the streets to oppose the savage cutbacks needed to secure an international bailout for the debt-laden government. Credit: Getty Images 
issue 12 October 2024

Historians in Ireland occupy a public role – unlike in Britain, where those with an inclination towards the commentariat usually migrate to America. This is perhaps not surprising in a country where public intellectuals are exemplified by Stephen Fry and philosophers by Alain de Botton. Ireland presents a more demanding prospect, where, ever since the days of Conor Cruise O’Brien, historians have colonised the public sphere with influential newspaper columns and regular debates on television. Indeed, when the national TV station began broadcasting in the early 1960s, it featured a discussion programme called The Professors, all of them historians (and one or two usually a bit the worse for wear).

The scale and pace of change in Ireland since the mid-1990s is seismic

Diarmaid Ferriter currently carries the flag for the historian-as-commentator, and does it with considerable élan. He is also far too hardworking to abuse the hospitality room. His punchy columns in the Irish Times are required reading on the issues of the day, and a stream of substantial books have dug deep into the modern Irish experience, covering revolution, civil war, social change, sexual behaviour and most recently the Irish border. His magisterial study of the 20th century was called The Transformation of Ireland – a title also applicable to his latest volume, where the word ‘revelation’ seems rather odd in the context.

Or maybe not if it means, rather than a stunning coup de foudre, the unveiling of something that was there all the time. Ferriter tells us that his earlier use of ‘transformation’ now seems provisional, and the new book, beginning in 1995, ambitiously charts the upheavals of economic boom and bust, the coming of uneasy peace to Northern Ireland, the crumbling of the social and political power of the Catholic Church, and above all the diversification of a society transformed by immigration: Gort, County Galway, where Yeats spent his summers, is now largely inhabited by a lively Brazilian community attracted by the local meat-packing industry.

GIF Image

Disagree with half of it, enjoy reading all of it

TRY 3 MONTHS FOR $5
Our magazine articles are for subscribers only. Start your 3-month trial today for just $5 and subscribe to more than one view

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in