Ryan Bourne

Increasing the minimum wage will only harm the lowest paid

‘If you earn £6 an hour flipping burgers then Allegra might have good news for you,’ said Jeremy Paxman on Newsnight yesterday. Paxman was of course introducing the mooted Conservative Party policy idea to increase the minimum wage, a story reported by Allegra Stratton. Stratton responded: ‘We’ve learnt that the Prime Minister’s advisors are thinking of turning Tory policy on its head and raising the minimum wage – not yet, but some time before the next election.’

For me, this brief exchange and the rest of the Newsnight piece reflected the state of the debate on this issue in the UK. First, Jeremy Paxman assumed that those flipping burgers would be able to keep their jobs if the national minimum wage was increased ‘significantly’. Second, the added barrier that a higher minimum wage would create for those young people or those with low skills from finding employment was not mentioned once – Stratton briefly touched on Treasury concerns about it causing unemployment, but there was no discussion of how it might affect new net job creation. Third, Stratton interviewed nobody who thought raising the minimum wage now was a bad idea. For balance, from the right we had David Skelton, in favour of the minimum wage increase ‘to broaden the Conservatives’ appeal’. And he was accompanied by James Plunkett of the Resolution Foundation, who thought that the minimum wage needed to increase because employers were taking advantage. So nobody who thought it might be a bad policy, despite the Low Pay Commission’s report this year being nuanced about the cost and benefits of raising the minimum wage and employers saying that it would be a bad idea in the economic climate.

Now I’ve written about why I think raising the minimum wage would be a bad idea here

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in