Letters: The BBC licence fee is an anachronism

Coronavirus predictions

Sir: While precautionary advice regarding the coronavirus should be followed, Ross Clark is right (‘Feverish imaginations’, 29 February) to urge an open mind on the doomsday predictions which are edging us towards panic. In 1996 the then government’s chief scientific adviser, Professor Kenneth Calman, predicted that 500,000 people could die within a few years from the human form of BSE. Another official adviser, Professor Richard Lacey, described the disease as ‘the time bomb of the 20th century, equivalent to the bubonic plague’. In the event, the reported death toll was 177, while the scare cost the UK an estimated £7 billion.

In 2005 the then government’s chief medical officer, Sir Liam Donaldson, warned that avian flu could kill 50,000 people in the UK. There is no public record of a single death. In July 2009 he told the NHS to plan for 19,000 to 65,000 deaths from ‘swine flu’ during that winter. The actual number of deaths was 457, and the government was left with 60 million doses of Tamiflu vaccine, which are said to have cost taxpayers around £500 million.
Maritz Vandenberg
London SW15

Licence to gripe

Sir: I am afraid Rory Sutherland misses the point in defending the licence fee (Wiki Man, 7 March). It has nothing to do with BBC content that we may or may not want. It is the fact that to watch any programmes on a TV, we have to pay for the BBC in its entirety, even if we watch none of it. In no other media is this the case. It is an anachronism — and sending people to prison for not paying Gary Lineker’s obscene salary is a disgrace.
John Watson
Crowborough, East Sussex

Exonerate Heath

Sir: An independent report by the former high-court judge Sir Richard Henriques into the Metropolitan Police documents in horrifying detail the malpractices which meant that ‘the names of Leon Brittan, Lord Bramall and others were dragged through the mud’(‘Trial and error’, 29 February).