Was this footballer killed for scoring against the Nazis?

Vienna, April 1938. To mark the Anschluss, the annexation of Austria by the Third Reich, the German football team plays a match against the Austrian team, which will cease to exist when the match is over. The Austrians are much better, but can’t seem to score – aha, the match has been fixed by the Nazis. And then, in the 70th minute, Austria’s best player, Matthias Sindelar, can’t take the pretence any more and puts the ball in the German net. At the end of the match, to underline his feelings, he performs a victory dance in front of the Nazi dignitaries. This might sound like fiction but it really happened.

Sindelar, the ‘Paper Man’ of this book’s title, was 35 at the time, and, in his prime, had been probably the best player in the world. He was a striker who drifted around the pitch, a bit like Messi or Cruyff – today we might call him a ‘false nine’. He was light and slender, hence the nickname. Manchester United wanted him, but he turned them down. He liked nightclubs and, people said, had lots of girlfriends. He was found dead along with a young Italian woman in his Vienna apartment in 1939. Did the Nazis kill him? Possibly. Was it a suicide pact? Less likely. Or was it carbon monoxide poisoning from a leaky gas pipe? We will never know.

In this imaginative, beautifully told fiction, we see Sindelar relaxing after the Germany match with his mates and his then girlfriend Rebekah, who is Jewish. The action cuts to Ireland in 1980, where Jack Shine, a 41-year-old Jewish stevedore, finds a box full of love letters written to his mother Rebekah from an Austrian footballer who died mysteriously in the year he was born.