Ed West Ed West

My idea for a new date in the calendar – Hate Speech Day

I know we’re inundated with ‘raising awareness’ days these days when we’re supposed to wear a bracelet or grow facial hair, but I’ve got a great idea for a new one – Hate Speech Day.

It occurred to me while reading this Atlantic piece about gay rights by Jonathan Rauch in which the author came out with a brilliant sentence explaining how liberal societies should work.

‘The best society for minorities is not the society that protects minorities from speech but the one that protects speech from minorities (and from majorities, too).’

Exactement! The best route towards maximum freedom, peace and happiness is through open debate, and that requires that all theories be tested, even the hateful ones.

America has a tremendous capacity for optimism and a belief in redemption and freedom, which is why the Civil Rights movement could emerge there, despite deep-seated racial animosity, and why gay liberation followed. I’d like to share Rauch’s view that gay equality won because it had the best product in the free market of ideas; but, being a miserablist Brit, I’d say it’s probably only two-thirds true; there is no true free market of ideas, because it’s just not human nature to accept things that ridicule or offend our beliefs, and sexuality is as open to censorship or self-censorship as any other area.

The evidence, as we know it, suggests that none of the fears about gay liberation have been borne out; that gays were more likely to be predatory to young people, that heterosexual adolescents could be turned gay, that gay equality would undermine heterosexual partnerships. But people who make the case otherwise should be allowed to make arguments without fear of boycott.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in