Fleur Macdonald

Repeat after me…

The fuss stirred up by the mere suggestion that poetry might be part of the school curriculum was extremely suspicious. Just as George Osborne quietly announced his u-turn on the charities tax during the less soporific sections of Leveson, the proposal that children should have to learn poetry off by heart smacked of a smoke screen.
 
What evil is lurking in the small print of Gove’s national curriculum? Will school dinners get even smaller? Have all our schools been sold to Google?
 
But when it comes to poetry, there seem to be two main objections to Gove’s plan. First, though Gove may ostensibly want to give teachers more freedom, this according to the National Union of Teachers is further proof of him tightening control over teachers and reducing their autonomy faced with the needs of individual children.
 
Secondly, as espoused by Simon Armitage in the Guardian, poetry should be ‘subversive’ and putting it at the heart of the national curriculum might be championing its ‘traditional’ values. Forcing children to learn it at school risks instilling a life-long aversion. On those grounds, perhaps we should drop maths and science too. In a sound riposte in the Independent to Armitage’s claims of the possibility of fermenting class warfare, Howard Jacobson argued: ‘As for the belief that &”a cultural inclination” should decide what you read and commit to memory and what you don’t, it is the very opposite of education: it is social engineering, a wickedly self-defeating egalitarianism whose only consequence is deprivation’.
 
However sensible the idea that poetry could even inspire and help children express themselves, it almost seems beside the point. Though this may make teacher training colleges shudder to foundations laid in the sixties, the skill of rote learning is fundamental to education as indeed is discipline and, to a certain extent, boredom.







Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in