Douglas Murray

The questions nobody wants to ask about Asad Shah’s murder

The questions nobody wants to ask about Asad Shah's murder
Text settings

On Maundy Thursday a Muslim shopkeeper in Glasgow was brutally murdered.  Forty-year-old Asad Shah was allegedly stabbed in the head with a kitchen knife and then stamped upon.  Most of the UK press began by going big on this story and referring to it as an act of ‘religious hatred’, comfortably leaving readers with the distinct feeling that – post-Brussels – the Muslim shopkeeper must have been killed by an 'Islamophobe'.  Had that been the case, by now the press would be crawling over every view the killer had ever held and every Facebook connection he had ever made.  They would be asking why he had done it and investigating every one of his associates.

But it soon emerged that although the Asad Shah murder was being treated by police as 'religiously motivated'  the suspected killer was in fact another Muslim who allegedly struck just hours after Mr Shah had posted a message on Facebook wishing a very happy Easter to his ‘beloved Christian nation’ and suggesting people follow in ‘The Real Footstep of Beloved Holy Jesus Christ'.  The murdered man’s family have now been advised by police to watch what they say and to disguise where they are in Britain because it is believed that they too could now be targeted.

Mr Shah was an Ahmadiyya (Ahmadi), a member of – against some stiff competition – one of the most persecuted sects within Islam.  Persecution against them in Pakistan and elsewhere around the Islamic world is rife.  Yet despite that (or perhaps for that very reason) they are probably the most peaceable and indeed admirable sect within Islam.  Among other things, Ahmadiyya Muslims formally reject the concept of Jihad that other schools cling to.  In Britain whenever there is a vaguely positive news story about Islam it almost invariably involves Ahmadi Muslims.  Remember the bus adverts a few years back saying that Islam had ‘love for all, hatred for none’.  That was paid for by Ahmadiyya Muslims.  Remember the stories of a Muslim group not burning poppies but actually selling them for the Royal British Legion? Ahmadiyyas again.

As I said, if the suspected killer of Mr Shah had been a non-Muslim things would have worked out differently.  But since he was reported to be a Muslim the story has now effectively gone dead.  The media aren’t that interested in follow-up and the politicians seem unbothered about following the hate-trail.  Like all other stories in this area, they don’t know what questions to ask and they don’t want to ask them anyway.  It's a familiar pattern.  Last Friday it turned out that the Imam of the Grand Central Mosque in Glasgow (Scotland’s biggest mosque) had been caught posting messages on the net praising the Muslim extremist who murdered Pakistani governor Salman Taseer for opposing blasphemy laws. This is the mosque that First Minister Nicola Sturgeon went straight to after the Paris terror attacks in November.  Did she ask whether the Imam was an Islamist? Perhaps she didn't know how to ask.  Like most people in our public life she is too willingly ignorant to ask such questions and wouldn’t like the answers anyway.

It is the same after the death of Mr Shah.  Ms Sturgeon went straight to a vigil in his memory.  But neither she nor any other politician so far as I am aware has bothered wondering why Ahmadiyya Muslims like Mr Shah might be targeted.  Of course in the days ahead we may hear the usual blandishments, but no blame will be apportioned.  So for instance nobody will ask which Muslim leaders in the UK stoke hatred of Ahmadiyya Muslims.  Either because they do not know, or because they do not care, nobody will ask Sadiq Khan about the killing of Mr Shah on Saturday.  If they did then Sadiq Khan would doubtless express horror for the killing and then talk (as he always does) of the need to ‘root out’ all such hatred.  But would anyone press on and ask whether the man most likely to be the next Mayor of London has ever ‘rooted out’ such hatred himself?  Will anyone ask Sadiq Khan about the views of the religious leaders at the mosque he himself attends?  I doubt it.  They would know what to do were Sadiq Khan a follower of almost any other religion, but such is the illiteracy in this country about a religion people really ought to know far more about by now that they will be silent.

As it happens, the Imam of the mosque that Sadiq Khan himself attends in Tooting is one Suliman Gani. This is a man who has in the past openly acknowledged that he uses his position to agitate against Ahmadiyya Muslims.  Indeed Sadiq Khan’s Imam has sat on a platform from which calls were made for Muslims to boycott shops owned by Ahmadi Muslims: Muslim shopkeepers, that is, like Mr Shah who was murdered last week.

As I say, nobody will ask about this, because almost nobody knows, or cares to know, or cares to hear the answers.  They would care deeply about webs of association if the man arrested for Mr Shah’s murder had been a non-Muslim.  But there is little to ask now it seems to be a Muslim.  That is how these things work in modern Britain, and that in a nutshell is why things are going to go so very wrong in the near future.

Written byDouglas Murray

Douglas Murray is Associate Editor of The Spectator. His most recent book The Madness of Crowds: Gender, Race and Identity is out now.

Topics in this articleSocietyislamsadiq khan