Sebastian Payne

With friends like the OBR, George Osborne hardly needs enemies

The Office of Budget Responsibility was created to be George Osborne’s friend. The theory was that under the leadership of Sir Alan Budd, the OBR would urge the Chancellor to cut. Budd would be listened to more than Robert Chote, who was then running the IFS. But when Sir Alan quit unexpectedly, Chote took over. Since then, the OBR has become the in-house prophet of doom. It not only points to a growth-free future for Britain, but keeps getting its forecasts wrong. It is proving laughably unreliable as a means for working out the likely effect of UK government policy.

In the Telegraph today, Doug McWilliams who wrote the original brief for the OBR, has attacked the current chairman for causing the Chancellor ‘no end of trouble’ and branded the organisation a ‘disaster’. In particular, McWilliams said the organisation has  ‘completely failed to understand how to bring in information from the outside’.

It’s easy to see where McWilliams is coming from. Examining the OBR’s forecasts over the past two years shows just how they lulled Osborne into a false sense of security two years ago, suggesting that his policies for prosperity would be enough. Take GDP — the OBR estimates have differed significantly from their first report (before the June 2010 budget) and their latest publication in March:

Their forecasts for unemployment have also differed slightly over the past three years:

Osborne’s biggest headache now is the soaring cost of living, with prices running way ahead of wages. The Chancellor even put up VAT, not knowing he’d just be piling on the pain for consumers who were to face the worst inflation in the EU.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.


Unlock more articles



Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in