A conflict of wills

It might seem odd that Eric Ives, the acclaimed biographer of Anne Boleyn, should turn his attention to another executed Tudor queen, Lady Jane Grey. As he points out, in the past six years alone, seven biographical studies of Lady Jane have appeared, and while this could be said to demonstrate the perennial fascination exerted by Jane’s short life and grim fate, the question inevitably arises as to whether even a scholar of Ives’s standing will be able to add much to what has been written. Yet it soon emerges that Ives is not primarily concerned with Lady Jane’s personal tragedy. Instead he focusses on the events that led to her being placed on the throne in July 1553, and the collapse of the regime 13 days later. The result is a major reinterpretation of this brief but exciting episode. 

In the spring of that year the Tudor dynasty was plunged into crisis when the teenaged King Edward VI developed a fatal lung infection. Edward’s late father, Henry VIII, had decreed that his daughters Mary and Elizabeth should inherit the throne in turn if Edward died childless, but in Edward’s remaining weeks of life secret documents were drawn up that excluded his half- sisters in favour of his cousin, Lady Jane Grey. When Edward died on 6 July, the 16-year-old Lady Jane was duly proclaimed Queen, and Edward’s entire Council pledged allegiance to her. However, when Mary decided to fight for her throne, a majority of those notables who had declared for Jane decided within days that the position was untenable and defected to her rival. With her crown wrested from her, Jane was condemned as a traitor and executed in February 1554.

Whereas it is usually supposed that unscrupulous adults manipulated the young King into denying the rights of Mary and Elizabeth, Ives demonstrates that Edward started tampering with the succession on his own initiative.