From the magazine

Consorting with the enemy: The Propagandist, by Cécile Desprairies, reviewed

The debut novel by a historian of the Vichy regime is a personal J’Accuse, indicting the collaborators in her family for their part in France’s collapse in the second world war

Lee Langley
Cécile Desprairies.  All rights reserved to Cécile Desprairies
EXPLORE THE ISSUE 17 May 2025
issue 17 May 2025

As a young child in the mid-1960s, Cécile Desprairies listened hour after hour to her mother Lucie dreamily recalling the 1940s, dwelling on a past peopled by undefined heroes and ‘the bastards’ who murdered them. Names were rarely mentioned or hastily passed over. In the fashionable Paris apartment there were daily gatherings – her mother, aunt, cousin and grandmother twittering like birds, obsessed with fashion and cosmetics. Between trying on clothes, there was endless looking back at a lost golden age and lamenting the disasters that followed. Lucie was always in charge, her second husband Charles, Cécile’s father, casually excluded. There was gossip about acquaintances, women with Jewish names described as ‘wealthy’, all apparently orphaned. There was no mention of the Holocaust, a word the child learned afterwards from books.

Decades later the silent observer began putting together the jumbled puzzle of the past, uncovering bit by bit the dark mystery of those years; to ferret out the reality behind the colourful social circle – a great-uncle, the toast of le tout Paris, who staged Mozart at the Opera House; the friends and family who magically acquired antique furniture or accommodation whenever needed. The picture she uncovered horrified her, and what began as an attempt at clarification sharpened into merciless exposure. 

Desprairies, a distinguished historian, has written several books about the Occupation and Vichy France. The Propagandist is her first novel, a vividly detailed story inter-woven with scorching truth, sensitively translated by Natasha Lehrer. It is a personal J’Accuse, indicting her mother and the family – a community of enthusiastic collaborators – for their part in the collapse of a country.

GIF Image

Disagree with half of it, enjoy reading all of it

TRY 3 MONTHS FOR $5
Our magazine articles are for subscribers only. Start your 3-month trial today for just $5 and subscribe to more than one view

Comments

Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months

Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.

Already a subscriber? Log in