Graeme Thomson

Dazzling – if you ignore the music: Beyoncé, at Murrayfield Stadium, reviewed

The sound was muddy and the songs don't cut it – but there's no denying the power of her voice

Opening night of Beyoncé's 2023 Renaissance World Tour in Stockholm. Photo: Kevin Mazur / Getty Images / Parkwood

Scheduling open-air concerts in mid-May in northern Europe is a triumph of hope over experience. I last spent time with Beyoncé – I’m sure she remembers it fondly and well – in 2016, in a football stadium in Sunderland on a damp, drizzly, early-summer English evening of the type that even strutting soul divas struggle to enliven. I don’t think it was merely the weather which left me underwhelmed by her brutalist attack, the sheer choreographed drill of the show, the lack of engagement, of spontaneity, of joy.

By then, Beyoncé was no longer seeking to be regarded as a mere pop star. She had recently taken on the unearthly qualities of an alien presence, entirely unrelatable, tilting for something far more culturally significant than a spot in the charts. She re-cast herself as cross-genre auteur, icon, uber-feminist, woman scorned and furious black rights’ campaigner. She did it with conviction. Plenty seemed persuaded.

The songs? Beyoncé isn’t really about the songs, a fact she seemed tacitly to acknowledge

Fast forward seven years and Beyoncé is both more totemic still and yet even less of a pop star than ever before. She doesn’t sell the most records, she has a dearth of tunes you can whistle on the bus, and she tours infrequently. Her most recent record, Renaissance, after which the tour is named, landed with the usual fawning fanfare but hasn’t really penetrated. It doesn’t seem to matter. She is simply Beyoncé, and that appears to be enough.

In Edinburgh, the weather was much the same as in Sunderland. Mild, damp, grizzly-grey. But something had changed. The mood felt more attuned to the Renaissance theme of celebratory transgression, its smorgasbord of black musical history powered by liberation, self-love and escape. There were nods to Rose Royce, Sade, Diana Ross, Kendrick Lamar, the Jackson 5, Megan Thee Stallion and Donna Summer.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in